What’s It All About?

I don’t know what the answer is and I am unsatisfied with what I have been told, therefore I am attempting to figure out what the answer is as best as my limited abilities will facilitate me.
I may be right or I may be wrong on any particular topic, but if right or wrong, at least I am trying to solve the question. By doing so, I am relieving myself of the burden of self imposed ignorance, since I would have rather tried and failed than to accept defeat without a fight.
You, my reader, are free to judge my words and thoughts and act as your mind and your conscience dictate.

Ben Stone
2011

Posted in Bad Quaker Theology, Brief Articles and Short Notes, The Campfire | Comments Off on What’s It All About?

The Stinky Sock and The State

Who doesn’t know this story?
The baseball player is in a hurry getting ready for a game and ends up wearing one clean sock and one dirty sock. He goes out on the field and has his best game ever. He’s convinced it’s the luck of the stinky sock. He never washes that sock again and wears it in every game until it falls apart. Then he saves a chunk of it and keeps it in his pocket. This story is played out in the sports world every day with thousands of different objects and thousands of athletes. Never mind that it is entirely a silly superstition that an object could be “lucky”, never mind that every athlete has good days and bad days, never mind that if there was luck it could have been the clean sock that was magic just as easy as the stinky one, never mind having the slightest bit of objective analysis, he believes in the Magic Stinky Sock of Luck.
What happened with the sock is often played out in a different way in the mainstream media. Some “expert” with an impressive title from some distinguished university gets a grant to study some topic. For the sake of this article, lets say Bill Smith PhD, believes you must be half deaf to enjoy Heavy Metal music. So Smith interviews 100 fans of Heavy Metal music at a concert. Smith is careful to divide his study group into different categories, male, female, smokers, non-smokers, under 30 years, under 20 years, full time employed, part time employed, unemployed, never employed, etc. In the process of eating up his grant money, he finds that 100% of the concertgoers show some degree of hearing loss at the end of the concert. Smith’s conclusion? People with hearing loss have a greater chance of becoming fans of Heavy Metal music than the general public. Clearly Smith’s conclusion is based not on logic, but on the results Smith wanted to draw from the beginning of his study. Of course you see Smith’s flaw because I used an obvious example, but a variation of this fallacy shows up in headlines with disturbing regularity.

Now for something completely different.
Mankind has made some amazing leaps in technology resulting in vast changes in the way we live. Without compiling pages and pages of subjective analysis along with supporting research, let me state that no person living today can fully appreciate the impact that the development of the control of fire had on humans. Some researchers have come a long way in understanding its impact, but without actually living in such a world it’s impossible to fully imagine life in those days. But someone, some individual person figured out how to control fire. This accomplishment along with the development of the hammer, blade, and the lever allowed humans to leap from being the hunted to being the hunter and from being the gatherer to being the planter. Every discovery or invention that individuals have made since that time pales in comparison to this group of technologies. With time, individual people used their new toys to develop farming and metallurgical skills and vast improvements in living standards were achieved. We are told that roughly 10000 years ago people were enjoying such luxuries as villages, farms, beer, religion, written communications, money, jewelry, beasts of burden, wagons, and a variety of textiles. Life was, relatively speaking, good.
One thing humans didn’t have in those days was the walled city. The first city walls that we know of were those of the “proto-city state” Jericho. This development is the single strongest indicator of the birth of the State, about 9000 years ago. This tiny infant of The Beast was not noticeable to the bulk of humanity at the time. Mostly people went about their business the same as they had for eons, farming, hunting, trading, and living their lives never knowing that a small pocket of their species were enslaved by a selfish entity obsessed with the blood sport of war and the consumption of taxes. And as far as we know, the next city-state didn’t develop for another 3000 years, but when it did it quickly morphed into the first empire. The Beast tried on his big boy pants and stomped around the yard for the very first time, plucking the wings off of weaker beasts while burning and torturing his subjects for sport.
City-states and empires came and went but never threatened humanity with anything other that localized tyranny until about 300 years ago when Europeans began to press their technological advantages into the service of the State. With stunning speed, the Beast spread its wings and engulfed continent after continent in its blood lust. In the last century it became almost impossible to find a remnant of free humans living without the burden of tax and the stench of war. During those 300 years a parallel event took place. Surges and sags in population aside, the sheer number of people alive at the same time in combination with that uniquely human tendency to tinker and invent, caused an explosion of thought, technologies, inventions, and scientific discovery.

Thus we have the myth of the stinky sock.
Often the uninformed and self-imprisoned masses confuse the one event as being the catalyst to the other. The stinky sock did not the champion create. The champion created the myth of the stinky sock. The same goes for the State and the current level of technological achievement. Often, I have heard people espouse nonsense about the State providing incentive for technologies to develop. Or worse yet, I have actually heard people credit war with economic development or even with scientific accomplishments. As if the destruction of goods and the slaughter of humanity could produce wealth and positive advances. The same people, who acknowledge the failure of the government postal service or admit the wholesale repression of individual achievement by government schools, somehow leap to their feet in praise of the State’s magical ability to inspire invention. All evidence to the contrary is ignored as the willing blind cling to their Hideous Master, never considering that it just could be that this Beast may have actually held society back, rather than advanced it. To the ball player, had he discarded his silly myth and practiced harder, not only would he be a better athlete but a better smelling one as well. So it is for humanity. When we finally discard this smelly Creature and give up the foolish myths it harbors, we can begin to become civilized and achieve what we are capable of becoming.

Just a few examples of the State hindering invention:

James Watt improves the steam engine with a small device. The state grants him monopolized protection and he spends the rest of his life and his fortune preventing anyone else from improving the steam engine. Progress on this one technology is held back for an entire generation.

Cotton gins are as old as history its self, but Eli Whitney overhears someone’s idea of an improvement to the device and uses the force of the state to grab a monopoly on its production, slowing the anti-slavery movement by artificially maintaining the profitability of the large plantations of the Antebellum era.

Orville and Wilber Wright, using their family’s vast political influence and their daddy’s gaggle of lawyers, sew up a monopoly on the production of aircraft in the United States. This in turn, stops all innovation of the new born technology in the western hemisphere. Fifteen years go by and while the Wright’s utilize the force of the State to control their dwindling market, Europeans free to innovate, push the technology ahead. Upon entry of the US into WWI, Americans can’t field a single aircraft of modern design and are forced to purchase their aircraft from the French and English.

During the 1920’s and early 1930’s individual inventors around the world take the first steps to bring us into the “Rocket Age”. At roughly the same time, other individuals begin developing the vacuum tube, and with it the first true computers. While others still seek the answers to the mysteries of the atom. The various nation states look at these three developing technologies and see a tool of destruction. All free market innovation is squashed and the Beast wraps one of his slimy tentacles around the collar of science. Some of the best minds of their age are crippled with the burden of facilitating mass murder like the world has never known. Computer technology is held back for 35 years before free tinkering individuals in their mother’s garage in Sunnyvale California give us what the State tried desperately to keep to itself. Meanwhile, a handful of entrepreneurs are still struggling with the State to bring the free market to space travel. And still after nearly 70 years, the Beast has such a mighty grip on the energy market that we can incinerate an entire city but cheap safe atomic power is still just a dream.

Therefore I conclude; For the freethinking logical individual, the State has all the appeal of a stinky sock and the faster it and the mythology surrounding it are rejected by civil society the faster that society can move ahead to a brighter more prosperous future.

Ben Stone

Posted in Bad Quaker and War., Bad Quaker Theology, History | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on The Stinky Sock and The State

A Little Story About Nothing

A Little Story About Nothing
Nothing but a deer trail

Imagine the late 1960’s.
When I was young my family lived in the Bay Area of California in what is now referred to as “Silicon Valley”. My father was quite worried about raising his family there considering we had a first hand, up close look at the San Francisco hippy movement, the Berkeley campus protests and riots, the constant news coverage of the Zodiac Killer, and Oakland heating up from the Black Panthers and the Hell’s Angles. In the Autumn of 1969 my family went camping on the western edge of Death Valley just off of a road called Goler Canyon Road. Upon our return home the news informed us that members of the “Manson Family” who were implicated in the Tate/LaBianca murders had been arrested at the Barker Ranch. That’s near Death Valley, just off of Goler Canyon. We had been camped within a mile or two of the Mansons. Needless to say, my mom was a bit freaked out about this. In 1971 Richard Nixon and his government made a series of moves that convinced my dad that the economy was about to collapse. My dad looked at the community around us and decided it was time to get out of Dodge. By the Spring of 1972 he had sold our house and we were on our way to Appalachia. My dad purchased our old family farm in eastern Kentucky and one of the most important periods of my life began.
One day in the Summer before my 13th birthday, I was wandering the woods of our 160 acre farm, all that was left of the 500 acres Tom Stone had claimed with his land grant, issued for his service in the Virginia Militia during the War of Independence. Near the very western edge of the property, I came across what I imagined to be an “Indian road”. I was very excited. Again, I was 12, almost 13 and had an imagination to match my age. This “road” was entirely hidden from view if you stepped 5 feet into the woods, but standing on it you could clearly tell how it went in each direction. I began hiking up and down it, amazed by something I knew I wasn’t understanding. You could take off running and easily follow the path without anything getting in your way, and yet you could never really tell where it was going for more than a few feet. After running up and down this road all day, I was forced by the failing sun to head home. At the dinner table I gleefully announced my discovery of the “Indian road” and how I was convinced that, as I ran up and down the road, I could tell there were Indian spirits running with me.
Well of course this gave my family a laugh and I was told that I had simply found a deer trail. They are everywhere in the woods. There were no Indian spirits. There was nothing unique or even interesting about my discovery. It was nothing but a deer trail. I was very discouraged and didn’t go back to that part of the property the rest of that year.
The next Spring, as I was out and about doing no particular thing for no particular reason, I found myself back in the general area of the trail. As I thought about the Summer before, I was feeling silly for thinking I had found something important. With in a few moments I realized I was standing on the trail. I had an undeniable feeling that I was not alone. I tried to shake the feeling by telling myself it was just a deer trail and there was nothing interesting about it. But the feeling was overwhelming. It was as if a thousand eyes were watching me. So I began to follow the trail. I followed it off of our property. When I got to a place where a road had crossed it, I picked it up on the other side. Fences cut across it. I came to a house with a big yard and it took me a while but I found where the trail picked up on the other side. I barely made it home before dark that night.
We only lived on the family farm for a few years and after the first time I never tried to tell my family about the Indian road. But I did go back and visit it several times. Each time I had that same feeling. Like a longing to follow it. Like I needed to follow it. When I would run on the road it seemed I could hear the voices of its past in my ears.
The entire experience was illogical and, even though I thought of it many times as I grew older, I always realized it was just the experience of a surfer kid from California dumped into the Appalachian woods. I had found nothing but a deer trail.

A few years back a new bourbon came on the market. I read a review and decided to give it a try. It was a nice bourbon with a very complicated flavor and a very inexpensive price. I learned its name came from an Indian road, called a trace, that used to lead in one form or the other from the Mississippi delta to the Great Lakes. The part that passed by the distillery was called the buffalo trace, thus the name of the bourbon, Buffalo Trace. Upon learning this information and discovering this wonderful bourbon, I hopped on Google Earth to see if I could see the distillery. To my amazement, I could see the trace. With the interruptions of modern life distorting it, I could still make it out on its whole route. I found something else. A branch of this trace cuts east by north east in almost a straight line from Frankfort Kentucky to the old river crossing west of Portsmouth Ohio where a huge Indian town had stood for perhaps thousands of years. The trace runs along the western edge of my old family farm.
For years I had no idea what any of this meant. I have often had the feeling that my life was following a trail just like that Indian road. But lacking any way to explain it or even prove it to myself, all I could ever do was keep these thoughts to myself. Until today.
What does all this mean? Maybe nothing. Its just a tail about a trail.

Thank you for reading this.
I warned you that this was a story about nothing.

Ben Stone
2010

Posted in Bad Quaker Theology, Brief Articles and Short Notes, History, The Campfire | Comments Off on A Little Story About Nothing

A General Theory of Liberty, Tyranny, and Sin

Disclaimer:

Because of the nature of the topic, allow me to be perfectly blunt so there are no misunderstandings to clear up later.
I am not writing nor re-writing scripture. I am not establishing an edict. Though I refer to the Christian Bible and both Jewish and Christian beliefs, this is not about any particular faith. An open-minded atheist should be able to see my point as easy as a theist. Finally, if your own personal faith is so dogmatic that you can’t consider any variation from it, please read no further.

Introduction:

To understand any given discussion it’s necessary to understand the terminology being used. In this situation I have chosen four words that can be and are understood in very different ways by different people. Therefore it will be helpful if the reader is clear as to my intended meanings of liberty, tyranny, sin, and God.

Liberty: a condition of freedom from control, interference, obligation, restriction, etc. or the power or right of acting, thinking, speaking, etc., according to one’s own choice

Tyranny: a condition where an individual or a group exercise domination over another individual or group using force or the threat of force

Sin: that which displeases God or is contrary to the will of God

God: that which created what is (For this discussion I don’t necessarily refer to an individual person or entity. Therefore the overall concept I am trying to get across is not dependent upon a belief system like Christianity. God, in this context, can be whatever you see as the source of our existence. It fits the atheist as well as the theist)

Liberty, Tyranny, and Sin

The beginning:

The Judeo/Christian creation story basically goes like this; After everything else is made, God makes Adam and Eve. He places them in a perfect place called Eden, tells them to be fruitful, multiply and fill the earth, and gives them only one rule. Namely, don’t eat the fruit of The Tree of Good and Evil. Survival Gear Bags Of course they eat the fruit and sin is introduced into mankind’s heart. God then ejects mankind from Eden. However, there’s a gap in this story. From the point that God commands them to be fruitful and multiply to the point that Adam eats the fruit, something must have happened. Some time must have expired, but nothing indicates how many hours, days, years, or eons of time pass. (more on this later)

What I propose to do is identify the fruit of that tree. What I will not do is dispute the volumes of traditional theological teachings about that fruit, so for the purpose of this discussion, please accept the possibility that I can be both right and wrong.

God’s will and sin:

The Bible tells a story in the book of 1st Samuel chapter 8 and it goes something like this; After roughly 500 years (the chapter doesn’t actually record the time, you have to do the math separately) in “The Promised Land” there was some unrest among the Israelite leaders. You see, during that time they had no central government. A series of “judges” resolved disputes both within the Jewish tribes and with their neighbors. These judges had no authority in the modern sense. People sought their judgment in matters and voluntarily accepted or rejected the results. It was a time described in the bible when “every man did that which was right in his own eyes”.

Generally speaking, the Israelites were free to come and go as they wished and trade with whom ever they wished for whatever they wished. When the need arose to confront foreign aggression the judges, being natural leaders, would rally volunteers and fight defensive battles. Near the end of these 500 years of relative liberty, the Israelites began to murmur and complain among themselves. It seemed Israel was situated between several great empires. These empires had magnificent cities where powerful kings sat on thrones of splendor. Many of the Israelites became covetous of the power of these empires, so they began to demand a king. The judge Samuel, at first, took this as a personal insult. But God corrected Samuel and said, “Its not you they reject, its me.”

So after 500 years of liberty, Israel subjected itself to tyranny. To make a long story short, within a couple generations the nation was split into two kingdoms and a couple generations later the northern half of the nation disappeared into the sands of time, never to be heard from again. Jerusalem, the capitol of the southern kingdom, was sacked and burned, the male royalty were mostly castrated, and the bulk of the people were taken into bondage as slaves of the very empire they had envied. They wanted all the fun part of tyranny but what they ended up with was what tyranny always produces. Slavery.

Isn’t that a lovely story? Here’s what I think; Its the same story as the one told in Genesis about Eden and the tree, just told in a different way about a different people in a different time.

The Interaction of Law and Sin:

Here I ask your indulgence. Let’s consider natural law as opposed to man-made law.
Question: What is the source of man made law?
Answer: Man!
Question: What is the source of natural law?
Answer: That which made man, God. (again, however you perceive God)

If we can agree on the above, then we can agree that to break natural law breaks the law of God and is a transgression against God. Therefore to break natural law is to sin against God. That being the case, logic demands that whatever breaks man’s law is a transgression against man. A “sin” against man. This train of thought then requires the question; Isn’t it the case that when man creates law he takes on the role of God?

Lets jump back to the Bible for a moment.

In the book of Ezekiel chapter 28, one finds the description generally believed to be the devil. Part of the description of this being says he was “perfect in beauty”, gifted in music, “perfect in his ways”, and originally located in Eden. This being had a flaw in his nature and eventually fell from grace, was cast down and rejected by God. His transgression was that he attempted to make a god of himself. Does this story sound familiar? I propose that story is in fact not about the devil, it is the story of man. It is the same story told two other times in this discussion.

I propose that when man chooses tyranny over liberty, man chooses sin. That liberty is the original natural state of man and when man takes it upon himself to regulate the behavior of other men he places himself in the position of God. I propose that when “Adam” chose to make up his own law he chose man as his god. He placed himself in the position of God and proclaimed himself a god.

The End of Time:

Christians and Jews have a variety of beliefs about the end of time.
I propose that “time” as we normally call it won’t end in the way most Christians and Jews think.
For this exercise, lets substitute the word ‘history’ for ‘time’. Consider history from the moment God told Adam and Eve to be fruitful and multiply, until the moment Adam ate the fruit. Where is this history? Was there no “time” or just no history? How many minutes or millions of years went by unrecorded?

Now think about history. What is history? I propose that history is the recording of the accomplishments and deeds of tyrants. When there are no tyrants, no history is written. Without tyrants heroes are unnecessary, taxes are not collected, and wars don’t happen. Time ticks on but there is no reason to record anything other than the passing of seasons for the purpose of planting and harvesting.

So what of the end of time? Change that to “what of the end of history?”

Many religions believe that someday there will be a return of sorts, to an Eden. I believe tyranny and the law of man will be rejected and humanity will choose liberty and Gods natural law will be universally adopted. That being the case, why would any history of that time be recorded? Time, in a way, will have ended.

Ben Stone
2010

Posted in Bad Quaker and Sin, Bad Quaker Theology, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

The Taking and The Following of Oaths

I am a Quaker. As such I hold to one of the basic characteristics of being a Quaker, namely; I don’t swear oaths of any kind. Period. We Quakers believe that not only is it clearly forbidden in scripture but prohibited by inference, additionally it is a matter of individual honor. If I have to raise my hand or any other ritual, and say magic words like, “I swear by ___ …” I am inferring that when I don’t follow these rituals or say these words I may be lying. In contrast, by aligning myself with The Religious Society of Friends (Quakers), I am stating to myself and to the world that I reject lies and embrace the truth even when the truth is uncomfortable or in conflict with my best interests.
So then, as someone who refuses to swear an oath or proclaim an allegiance or give honor to an inanimate object, one could ask what right I have to question the oath or allegiance of others. I would answer this charge by saying that since I am not biased by any oath nor is my allegiance encumbered, I am then a qualified judge of those who will attempt to convince me by their oath or their ritual.

Now then, lets consider a popular oath about an inanimate object.

I, (NAME), do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; and that I will obey the orders of the President of the United States and the orders of the officers appointed over me, according to regulations and the Uniform Code of Military Justice. So help me God.

Have you, the reader, ever taken such an oath? If so, did you mean it? Are you still, today, faithful to this oath? Do you see this oath as a temporarily agreement, or a solemn and permanent pledge?

Think about this for a moment. The liberal minded person reads the Second Amendment of the Constitution and then bends it and twists it to support the notion that a person has no right to own a gun. Or he may just discount it as a remnant of a time before people were as “enlightened” as he and his liberal friends are today. But the Second Amendment is quite clear and founded on the basic notion that each individual person has a right to self protection and ownership of weapons. Do you, the reader, the swearer of oaths, the defender of the Constitution, believe the Second Amendment should be brushed aside? Ignored? Translated using the modern “enlightened” mindset?
Then what about Article I, Section 8 of the same document?
Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution says “The Congress shall have Power To…” and then it begins to list each act of the government that is assigned to Congress. The plain reading is that these powers are the duty of Congress and no other part of government, since no one else is mentioned. To believe someone else may share these powers is to assume something into the Constitution that it simply does not say.
Some examples of the responsibilities of Congress from Article I, Section 8;
“To define and punish Piracies and Felonies committed on the high Seas, and Offenses against the Law of Nations;”
Notice, this is not the president’s job, neither is it the job of the justice department nor any other department that answers to the president, according to the constitution.
“To declare War, grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water;
To raise and support Armies, but no Appropriation of Money to that Use shall be for a longer term than two Years;
To provide and maintain a Navy;
To make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and naval Forces;” (sic)
These provisions of the Constitution appear to be entirely forgotten or willfully ignored. Now days, its the president’s decision that takes us into war. Survival Gear Bags Oh sure, we have new definitions for these words, but the intended meaning of these sentences is abundantly clear. The framers of the Constitution and the original adopters of this document clearly placed the decision to go to war in the hands of congress, not the president. And with the most basic glance at history its easy to see that the reference to armies being funded for no longer than two years was not intended to mean that congress could just re-approve a budget every two years and have an eternal army permanently occupying at least 135 foreign countries. Only the Navy was authorized to exist year after year. The Army was to be on an as needed basis. Clearly the Constitution is being openly violated by the very government that claims to be based upon it.
You may say, “Oh, but you don’t understand. Times have changed. Things are different now.” My response would be, “You swore to this document, not an imaginary one.” Now you cry, “Oh, but how would we maintain peace? How would we protect our friends?” I would answer, “You swore the oath. Does your oath have meaning?”

This brings us to a question that I can pose, but I cannot answer on behalf of the oath giver; What is an honest person to do? Within the heart of each individual lies the answer to that question, but I feel I can probe around the edges and maybe shine some light on the matter. First and foremost, don’t be fooled into thinking this oath was given to any specific government or group of people. A quick reading of this oath will show that this oath is a public proclamation of a self imposed commitment. It is a contract with yourself, witnessed by others. One could justify breaking it by simply stating that it was a misunderstanding. That the oath giver didn’t fully understand the repercussions of the oath. As long as the swearer is comfortable with that in their own heart, I don’t think anyone could justly condemn them. However some may feel more of an obligation to what they stated in the oath to be a solemn, and therefore not to be entered lightly or without thought, oath, proclaimed before man and God and based upon their sacred honor. To the person who feels this way, I simply see no path but to uphold this oath or break it and admit dishonor. So then, what would “uphold this oath” mean? What should this person do? When faced with orders that fly in the face of the Constitution, given by a government that has wholly abandoned that Constitution, what is an honest person to do?

I propose the oath be either abandoned and the Constitution abandoned with it, or upheld and enforced as the law of the land. These States that span North America are in the grip of an entity that openly violates the Constitution thousands of times a day. I propose that Constitution is void by the fact that the federal government of These States has abandoned it and is operating in open violation of it. Therefore if that Constitution is to be made alive again, either the current government must cease and desist all unconstitutional activity or a new convention must be established and a new government must be installed in accordance with that Constitution.

As for my part in the matter, I am entirely neutral. In my opinion, you may have this government or have a new one, ultimately the results will be the same. I have no horse in this race as I have no loyalties, oaths, promises, or commitments to this government or this Constitution or any other. I have no moral obligation to an organization that supports itself by theft and force. I find myself much the same as the man being robbed. The thief has a gun to my head and is taking my wallet. I will not assist him, but it would be foolish to fight him on his terms.

Ben Stone
2011

Posted in Bad Quaker and the Constitution of The United States, Bad Quaker and War., Bad Quaker Theology, Voluntaryism and Law | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

My Natural Progression from Libertarian Theist to Quaker

I’ll make every effort here to avoid allowing this to turn into a history lesson. Considering my love of history, that’ll be no easy feat. I will at very least, need to give some historical background in order for the reader to grasp the depth of the connection between the origin of libertarianism and that of Quakerism. Murray Rothbard, maybe more than anyone else, has shown that modern libertarianism is founded on the thinking of a wide array of historical figures going back to antiquity, however libertarianism as I see it, began to codify with late seventeenth and early eighteenth century English writers. I believe the desire for liberty at that time and place was sparked by the trauma of having seen first hand, the excesses of tyranny placed upon England by Cromwell and his Roundheads. The spread of Quakerism in England and in the American colonies, I believe, was a reaction to that same tyranny imposed by the religious arm of the Roundheads, the Puritans. That is to say, Puritanism taken to its logical end is a combination of religious, governmental, and societal tyranny whereas Quakerism is exemplified in religious and societal tolerance and its logical political end is the non-aggression principle, which is the foundation of libertarianism.

To the degree that England and the colonies were subjected to the tyranny of Puritanism, the liberty minded individuals were driven towards Quakerism and libertarianism. And since State begets State as evil begets evil, when the Puritans fell from power the restored monarchy and its parliament, invigorated by Cromwell’s “New Model Army”, pushed free minded individuals further towards either libertarianism or Quakerism according to their predisposed positions. Both libertarianism and Quakerism are radical reactions to oppression. By that I mean to say, if no one is oppressing you and you’re free to go about your life without restrictions, religious, social, or political, you have a tendency to not think about liberty. It’s like air. If you have all you need you don’t think about it. But if someone takes it away you quickly realize its importance and you will react to that denial of air in direct proportion to the extent it is denied. So with the defeat of the English in the colonies there was a loosening of the shackles of oppression and likewise a relaxing of the impulse to abolish the State. Much like old Rip Van Winkle, libertarianism in the western hemisphere drank from the jug of complacence and sat down in the shade for a nap. The newly formed American government was, relatively speaking, held in check. And with more western land becoming available, anyone feeling choked by the State could simply move away from it.

Quakerism, however, saw no relief from the stranglehold of the religious ideologues. While the “good religious folks” of New England were denying property rights to natives, treating women like second class citizens, and owning humans as slaves, the Quakers were pointing out this hypocrisy and proclaiming that all people are created equal and endowed by their Creator unalienable Rights. Eventually, like the libertarians, the Quakers found a degree of victory and became less important in America. However, unlike the libertarians, Quaker ideas didn’t get set aside. A far more dastardly method was used against Quakerism. The State feigned acceptance of Quaker demands by “protecting” the natives (reservations and handouts) “freeing” the slaves (murderously denying secession) and “empowering” women (economic destruction requiring two incomes per family).

 

At this point we must turn away from history and clarify the two words I’ve been tossing about with such careless abandon. What does it mean to be libertarian and what does it mean to be Quaker? Both these words bring almost instant confusion to the average American. Both conjure up inaccurate images that have been spoon fed to Americans by the State through its puppets in Hollywood, the schools, and the media. Associating them with things they don’t remotely resemble has systematically discredited both. So to begin the clarification process, allow me your indulgence while I explain what libertarians and Quakers are not.

Quakers:

Quakers are not Amish nor are they Mennonites.

Quakers do not shun modern inventions like electricity and zippers.

Quakers do not use buggies for transportation.

Quaker men are not required to have beards and Quaker women are not required to wear dresses styled in the 1800’s.

If you walked past a Quaker in a shopping mall there would be no way of knowing the person was a Quaker.

Just to make sure I’m getting the point across, Quakers are not Amish nor are they Mennonites.

One last point, Quakers are not Amish nor are they Mennonites.
Are we clear on this?

 

Libertarians:

Libertarians are not dope heads.

Libertarians are not pro-dope.

Libertarians do not want your children to have dope.

Are we seeing a pattern here?

Libertarians do not believe people should be able to “do what ever they want”.

Libertarians are not “liberal on some things and conservative on others”. (Libertarianism is consistent.)

Libertarianism is not pro-corporation nor is it pro-business.

Libertarianism is neither anti-corporation nor anti-business.

Libertarianism is not “against the Federal Reserve”.

Libertarianism is not “for the gold standard”.

 

Often, when a person attempts to understand another person’s political position, they will ask questions like, “Do you support policy A?” or, “Do you think B is a good law?” You can never come to an understanding of libertarianism by asking such questions because libertarianism is not a political position. Libertarianism is a philosophy based on a very narrow set of principals. The more thoroughly the individual adheres to those principals the more consistently libertarian they are.

Every individual person, by the simple fact that they are alive, owns property. Their life is their property and can rightfully belong to no one else. Additionally an individual owns other property that they have rightfully acquired through trade, by gift, or by homesteading previously unowned property. Survival Gear Bags A person may defend their property but no person or group of people can ever rightfully initiate aggression against the property of another person. Individuals are responsible for their own actions and cannot be responsible for the actions of another. This is the simplicity and the elegance of the libertarian philosophy. Libertarians reject theft, aggression, and lies while embracing ownership, peace, and responsibility.

There was once a Person who taught just such a philosophy. The words He used were a bit different, but the meaning was clearly the same. He said things like, “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” and He taught us that God is not impressed with fancy costumes, titles of honor, or man-made authority and neither should we acknowledge such things. So when I say that Quakerism taken to its logical political end is libertarianism, its because both have the non-aggression principal as their foundation and both promote an equal respect for individuals, recognizing that no one human has the right to demand the servitude of another.

In the old days Quakers suffered many strikes of the lash for refusing to remove their hat and bow to State dignitaries. They caused a fuss by refusing to swear allegiance to the symbols of those who sought deification by giving themselves such titles as Lord or Governor or Bishop. Quakers even went so far as to refuse to use self-glorifying titles and refused to call others by them. Quakers felt no obligation to attend services at or pay money to support buildings were men stood on perches and spoke down to congregations. All these things were quite upsetting to those who did dress up in silly costumes and adorn themselves with ridicules titles of honor.

Oddly enough, however, to attempt to understand Quakerism by asking a series of questions like, “Do you believe in Doctrine A?” or “Do Quakers believe B?” is a misguided path that will likely never produce a consistent result. Quakers differ greatly in their individual beliefs. Some strictly believe a particular version of The Bible, while others have a far less structured religion. Quakers are more defined by their actions than the particular details of how they view theology. Much like the non aggression principle is to libertarians, Quakers adhere to something we call “testimonies”.

An example of a list of testimonies would look like this:
Peace
Equality
Integrity (or Truth)
Simplicity
Stewardship (or Sustainability)

So for example, a Quaker’s testimony of peace is to refuse to aggress. Many Quakers take their testimony of peace to the point of even refusing self-defense, but not all Quakers are pacifists. A Quaker’s testimony of integrity is to refuse to lie. This has caused some confusion in courtrooms when Quakers have refused to “be sworn in”. The Quaker contends that the very fact that they are speaking indicates they are not lying. And to repeat some magic words while raising or lowering one’s hand or placing it on some object, indicate that without such rituals a lie is acceptable. So the “testimonies” of a Quaker are not simply words or doctrines, they are the day-to-day living actions of the individual.

At this point, if I have done my job in a satisfactory manner, it should start to become clear why I say that Quakerism is the natural result of applying libertarian principals to theology and libertarianism is the natural result of applying Quaker principals to politics. However, if you don’t agree with me I won’t attempt to force you.

 

Ben Stone
2011

Posted in Bad Quaker Theology, History, The Campfire, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Waffle People, or why everything you know about anarchism may be wrong

Once upon a time in a land not so very far away, there was a very happy kingdom called Waviles.

Waviles had a wise, kind old king who was beloved by his people. The kingdom was located among steep mountains and was naturally guarded on every approach by towering cliffs. The people always felt safe since there was but one heavily guarded pass leading into Waviles and it had never been conquered. Because of its remoteness, very few people ever visited or even knew about Waviles.

One day a traveler was wandering in the mountains and came upon the pass leading to Waviles. He saw that the road was seldom used and decided it would be a good path to take to learn of new places. This traveler was a happy, healthy man, not known for his intelligence, but loved by his friends for his good cheer and his simple honesty. He made his way past the checkpoints unaccosted since he presented no danger in the eyes of the guards and once through the pass a wide valley stretched out before him with a village in the distance. Survival Gear Bags When the traveler reached the village he spotted the town cobbler who was in front of his shop showing off a new pair of tall black boots he had just finished. The cobbler happened to be eating a thin rolled waffle filled with fruit and cream, and had just taken a huge bite. “What land is this and by what name is this village known, friend?” said the traveler to the cobbler.
The cobbler, his mouth still occupied with his lunch said, “Is Waviles.”
The traveler misunderstood the man to say, “waffles” and assumed he had not been clear with his question.
“No, no, not the treat. The land, my friend, what is the name of this land? This kingdom?”
Again the cobbler tried to speak with food in his mouth, “Waviles! Kingdom of Waviles and land of Waviles.”
Unfortunately having never heard the word Waviles, the traveler assumed the man was saying “Waffles”.
“Funny name for a village or a land.” the traveler mumbled.
Again with a stuffed mouth the cobbler said, “Is our dear king’s name as well, Good King Wavile, rest his soul.” but at this point the traveler was only half listening. He had spotted an old lady drawing water from a well and decided to try to engage a conversation with someone who didn’t have a mouth full of food.
Now it so happened that just the day before the good king had died. As was the custom, the new king wouldn’t be crowned until after the old king was cremated.
The traveler walked up to the old woman at the well and asked, “Dear woman, can you help me? I’m confused about this king of yours and your land.”
The old lady shook her head and said, “Bless him, the kings not living. Don’t you know?”
The traveler was more confused than ever. “Here now, I’m confused. Am I to understand your king is a waffle?”
She almost laughed at his foreign pronunciation. “Our king’s a Wavile. He was the son of a Wavile and the next king will be a Wavile as well.”
So having completely misunderstood every bit of information that had been passed to him, the traveler filled his water jug, bought some provisions and began to leave the land of Waviles, or “Waffles” as he understood it to be. As he left town he noticed strands of black cloth hanging from windows and from eaves. Odd he hadn’t noticed before. Looking up the hill he spotted the castle with black flags waving from every parapet. Just down the hill a bit, people were stacking wood in a great mound. The traveler stood gawking for a moment trying to take in what he saw when another villager said to him, “Makes a fellow want to cry, it does.”
“What’s that?” said the traveler.
“Well, it’s just that I loved the Old Man. I hate to see them burn him like that. I know it’s the way, but it doesn’t seem proper to me, is all. I just hate to see him burn.”
‘They burn their elderly!’ thought the traveler, ‘I must leave this land with all haste!’

After some time, the traveler made it back to his own land and to his own village.
Day after day he would go to the local pub and tell the stories of his travels. Exotic far away lands with strange animals. People of different skin tones and various cultures. Strange foods and odd spices and interesting buildings were described in great detail by the traveler, but the one story that always finished the night, the one everyone waited for after long hours of talk and drink, was the story of the Waffle People. Everyone loved the story of the Waffle People. Those odd folk that waved black flags, wore big black boots, euthanized the old, and not only ate waffles but sat a waffle on a throne and bowed to it as their king! Talk of these strange people would continue even after the traveler gave up for the night and went home. Late at night with more and more drinks flowing, the story of the Waffle People would grow and take on new oddities and the story would twist in every direction as others would say they too had heard of Waffle Land and of this waffle on a throne.

As the traveler aged, his memory slipped and more and more he relied on the folks at the pub to help him with his stories. Eventually the old gent passed on, but the story of the Waffle People continued to grow. Yes, it was known that in Waffle Land everyone wore big black boots. Man and woman alike wore the boots. Actually men and women dressed exactly alike in all black from their heads to their toes! In the midst of these wild speculations, someone pointed out that pirates on the high seas often use the black flag! Others said the black flag was a sign of plague! Could it be that pirates infected with some mind altering plague had taken refuge in those mountains?
Eventually specific “facts” about Waffle Land and its evil Waffle People became common knowledge.
Namely:
1) Waffle People were a race descended from pirates, infected by an illness that twists the mind.
2) They live in a village where every house is made of waffles.
3) They kill off their old as soon as they reach the age of 30 years!
4) The only food they eat is waffles and they drink a strange brew made of waffles and the ashes of their dead elders.
5) They worship an idol of their God-King, The Great Waffle, set in a huge black hall covered in black tapestries.
6) Only one man has ever set foot in Waffle Land and come out alive. He was driven to madness and drank himself to death over what he saw there.

As new generations heard and passed on the lore of the Waffle People different people reacted to it in different ways.
An odd little traveling “holy man” ranted about the evils of waffles in general. Teenagers took to wearing black garb. Black boots were all the rage among the young. Mothers worried about their children and old men talked about how the Waffles were corrupting society. Watchmen at night would occasionally sound the alarm thinking they had seen a Waffle lurking in the darkness.
Now to be honest, some people knew that this whole “Waffle Land” was a huge misunderstanding. The local magistrate often laughed at the silly uneducated hordes with their foolish superstitions. He and the High Priest discussed how handy it was to have these “Waffles” around. For example, when it was found that the coinage had been debased and worth only a third of its perceived value, it wasn’t hard for the village to believe the Waffles were working among them to rob them of their wealth with counterfeit coins! Of course the magistrate solved that problem by confiscating all the coinage and replacing it with official script. Then there was the time the cathedral was robbed of the relief fund that had been gathered for the poor. Anyone could see the hand of the Waffles in such a deed. It’s a good thing the magistrate stepped up with the emergency relief tax, otherwise the poor would have starved that winter.
For the protection of the village, some new laws were enacted. First and foremost, no wearing of boots or any black cloth. No making, buying, selling, or possessing waffles or waffle making devices. And lastly, worship of The Great Waffle was strictly forbidden under penalty of death.
Even with these carefully crafted laws, things seem to be getting worse and worse. Young people began openly defying authority, wearing their black boots and even waving black flags! Sometimes groups of young “Wafflers” would knock over waste bins or set haystacks on fire.

It was about this time another of the villagers decided he wished to travel and see strange places. Traveling from place to place he was careful to avoid the “Black Pass” that was the legendary entry to Waffle. After a while he decided to return home so, taking the most direct route, he came almost too near the entrance of the pass. Survival Gear Bags There he saw an old man pushing a wagon in the direction of the evil pass, so he shouted to him, “Hey there, stop! Are you a stranger to these lands? Worse than death awaits you on that road.”
The man stopped and asked, “Here now, of what do you speak?”
The traveler told the tail to the old fellow, faithful to all the details that he was so sure of.
“That’s silly nonsense young man! How did you come to have such notions?”
The traveler explained again, the evils of the Waffle People.
“I’m telling you that’s nonsense! First off its not Waffles, its Waviles. I happen to be a Wavile on my mother’s side and lived there near half my life.”
But the traveler would hear none of it. In his mind, he knew what he believed was right and no matter what the old man said it wouldn’t change what the traveler believed.

Well, this has been a long story and you’re likely asking yourself why you’ve read this far. If you’re a libertarian or consider yourself an anarcho-capitalist, you’ve likely already seen the comparison. Then again, maybe its not completely obvious. When a liberty loving anarchist or libertarian talks to pretty much anyone outside of our movement we can almost be certain they have a preconceived notion of who we are and what we stand for that is every bit as wrong and twisted as the picture painted of the Waviles by the fools in the story above. Terminology has systematically been twisted by a combination of ignorance, happenchance, and the concentrated efforts of evil people so that we are virtually guaranteed to be misunderstood by the hordes. Lies abound and accusations of assassinations, wars, bombings, and mayhem have all been falsely attributed to us and these lies have been told so often and with such conviction that some of us have even believed them at times. Sadly, the vast majority of Americans today have no interest in learning the truth about us or about liberty, and many who say they’re with us are only in it for the cool boots. After all, at the moment, we’re a bit of a fashion craze. But that will pass with time and we’ll simply be misunderstood again soon.

This is the ethical foundation that all of Liberty is based upon;
The Philosophy Of Non-aggression ~ The initiation of physical force against persons or property, the threat of such, or fraud upon persons or their property is unethical when done by a single person or a group.
Right of Property ~ Each person is the exclusive owner of his or her body, life, and actions and is exclusively responsible for their body, life, and actions. Each person owns the product of their own labor, and any previously unowned resource that they acquire or improve (homestead). A person may use, improve, destroy, sell, trade, or give as a gift any item they rightfully own. A person owns what they have homesteaded, purchased, traded for, or were rightfully given as a gift. When a person violates the non-aggression principal they forfeit their right of property pursuant to their act of aggression.
Law ~ The Non-aggression Principle coupled with The Right of Property are the only true Law.

It seems odd that people with such a simple philosophy would endure so much ignorant abuse by those who believe what they were told rather than seek truth.

Ben Stone

Posted in The Campfire | Tagged , , , , , , , | 1 Comment