0053 The Tragedy of the Commons

Property, Part 1
0053 The Tragedy of the Commons MP3
(audio player below article)

The Tragedy of the Commons
by Ben Stone

I’m starting this series on property by jumping into the middle of the topic rather than establishing a base and then building on it. My reason for this approach is that since socialism has crept into so many aspects of our lives, it’s often hard to recognize it when we’re looking right at its devastating consequences. This familiarity with evil causes us to accept the notion that some things are the way they are by nature, so we don’t see the cause/effect aspect of the problem. Having failed to identify the problem’s source, we are more easily sold a statist/socialist solution without even realizing it, which of course makes the problem worse. So then, by directly confronting the primary effects of socialism, among which are over usage, shortages, hording, and ultimately rationing, it’s my hope to sharpen the reader’s skill at spotting the lies of socialism whenever they appear.

Ketchup
Four college students, Tom, Bill, Fred, and Larry, decide to move off campus and rent a house. This seems to make sense because it will afford them more individual space and free them from the rules of the dormitory. So a suitable house is found and they quickly move in, not realizing they’re leaping into a social experiment that may render them all enemies, fighting over a bottle of ketchup.

On the very first day, Tom mentions to the others how funny it is to look in the refrigerator and see two milk jugs, three bottles of orange juice and four bottles of ketchup, yet there is no butter, cheese or eggs. Bill suggests a budget be established and basic food supplies be purchased using equal contributions from each of the four, but specialty items that individuals buy for themselves be kept separate. Everyone agrees this is the logical way to avoid conflicts over what belongs to whom and who owes whom for what. Four cabinets are selected and designated and zones in the refrigerator are assigned. They make a list of basic supplies and each student throws $25 into a hat. Tom takes the list and the cash and heads to the store, all the time thinking how nicely they solved their first potential problem.

After some time passes and the newness of the house wear away, Tom begins noticing some differences among the group. For example Bill usually skips breakfast, as he has an early class and can never seem to get up in time. Fred wakes up early and over the course of the morning consumes two or three bowls of what Tom considers “kid’s cereal”. Larry always wakes up mid-morning and has a three-egg omelet, which he covers in ketchup. This strikes Tom as particularly odd since he has never heard of people putting ketchup on eggs. Seeing Larry desecrate his food in this manner turns Tom’s stomach. The very though of the mess is more than Tom can handle before he has his coffee.

Tom is not alone in his observations. Bill, who almost never drinks milk and only occasionally has an egg, is beginning to wonder why he has to constantly chip in for more supplies while consuming the least of the group. However, in all fairness, Bill is the one who made that first list which included milk and eggs, so he doesn’t feel comfortable making a big deal out of it. After all, he tells himself, it probably all evens out in the long run. However, Bill is beginning to become frustrated with Larry due to his habit of leaving his stinky shoes wherever he flops down when he comes back from jogging every afternoon. And Tom is starting to get on Bill’s nerves with his tendency to constantly be cleaning everything over and over.

Larry doesn’t notice any of the things Tom and Bill are beginning to obsess over. He has never had so much fun. The freedom of being away from home and the excitement of living in a collage town keep Larry smiling all the time as he enjoys this wonderful life with his new friends. Fred feels pretty much the same way. Having grown up in a large family, this is the first time he can truly have his own stuff and not have to share with his little brothers and sisters. The freedom to buy a bag of frozen curly fries, tossing them in the oven, then sitting back in his room and watching what he wants to watch on TV while eating every bite without sharing one fry just thrills Fred. And he gets to have his fries the way he likes, very crispy and covered with ketchup and extra salt. Plus he gets the same satisfaction from his Frosty Flakes in the morning. He can eat all he wants and never has to worry about someone else emptying the box before he gets up.

Then one day Tom was running the vacuum cleaner in the living room and had to stop to move Larry’s shoes. Bill took the opportunity to point out that Larry is the only one that leaves his stuff lying around everywhere like that. While Tom agreed the shoes were a problem, he pointed out how Bill leaves his shaving supplies all over the bathroom. Bill had never thought about it like that, but in defense Bill asked why it is that he is the only one who takes the trash out of the bathroom. Clearly something had to be done about all of this. About this time Larry walked in from the kitchen with an empty ketchup bottle and announced that somehow all the ketchup was gone. Bill asked what happened to the four bottles and Tom answered with a scowl, that Larry saturates his eggs in it every morning. Larry was devastated. For the first time he realized Tom’s opinion of him, and it seemed these two were ganging up on him. He tried to defend his use of ketchup by saying that he only had a small amount each time, but to no avail. Bill agreed with Tom that it was time Larry make up for his ketchup consumption! So Larry put on his shoes and headed for the store. From then on Larry made sure he put all the ketchup he wanted on his eggs. After all he wanted to get his money’s worth since he’s being blamed for everything.

After a few days, Larry was still angry about how his friends had ganged up on him. So one evening he decided to treat himself to an omelet and just dare someone to say something! Except when he went to the refrigerator to grab the ketchup there was none! As it turned out, Fred had taken the bottle into his room to enjoy some curly fries and had failed to return it! So Larry accused Fred of hording the ketchup! Bill tried to calm the situation by suggesting a system of ketchup allotments and Tom agreed that it sounded fair. But this was too much for Larry! He pointed out how Tom was the one who started this whole thing about ketchup on the first day and how Bill’s money schemes had lead to these shortages to begin with. All of that along with how Tom is always making noise running the vacuum is starting to get aggravating. (Oddly enough, before the ketchup issue Larry was never bothered by Tom’s cleaning routine.)

Ownership and Responsibility
When you are the sole owner of a thing you are solely responsible for that thing. If you damage it, improve it, or consume it, you only have yourself to answer to for the condition of the thing. But when ownership of a thing is shared vagueness and layers of arbitrary rules fog the responsibility for that thing. The loss of responsibility manifests itself in over usage, shortages, hording, and ultimately rationing. And since shared ownership is contrary to human nature, anger and frustration are the typical emotions that result.

In our example above, we see commodities like ketchup, eggs and milk being consumed disproportionately, while common resources like the living room and the bathroom are being abused or even polluted, at least this is the case in the opinion of some. We also see labor being misallocated and we see the frustration and the anger that, when taken to the level of a nation, erupts in strikes, protests, and marches and in the end, State violence and suppression of individuals. But what we don’t see is anyone upset about curly fry or the Frosty Flake consumption. The difference being that the curly fries and the Frosty Flakes were clearly the property of one person. We also don’t see a shortage of fries and flakes, as the owner is the sole responsible party.

The reality is that almost all conflicts boil down to property rights. When the right of property is correctly addressed almost all other differences become trivial. The more individuals apply the principles of property rights to their lives the less confusion and misunderstanding have a place in the conversation. This goes back to the old saying, “Good fences make good neighbors.” The reason this statement has passed the test of time and criticism is because it’s based on a natural respect for the right of property and an understanding that the more defined the dividing line that separates your property from mine the more comfortable we both are with that which we own.

So then, what are the principles of property rights?
Property is that which can be owned. First and foremost, that would include one’s self. And in the same manner, you can own no one but yourself and no one can own you. Age, health, or other physical condition does not alter this foundational truth. Others may be able to use violence or the threat thereof against you, but this doesn’t indicate ownership. Additionally, there is only one of you, therefore you are in limited supply and you can only be in one place at a time. While you are in that place, no one else can occupy that space. Therefore you naturally own the space you occupy. And since you are not divisible, one cannot rightfully share one’s self.
You have the ability to act. Unlike a rock or water, humans can choose to act or not act. Our actions can cause work to be accomplished and the result can be more property. That property will have things in common with that which we have already established as property. It must occupy space and be in limited supply. When our actions produce property, we are the natural owner of that property. When we produce property we have the right to keep, sell, trade, abandon, or give that property as a gift. Also unowned or undiscovered property can become owned property by homesteading which means mixing ones labor with the property and/or occupying that property.
Now if we take this primary example of property and apply it to other things, we can begin to understand what can and what cannot be property and therefore what can and cannot be owned.
Space can be owned, since we own the space we occupy and we can homestead new space. However outer space cannot be owned because it is not in limited supply. So only that space that has defined boundaries can be owned, as this characteristic creates a limited supply. If you could fence in some defined area of outer space and improve it or occupy it, you could own that defined space, but not all of outer space.
The same goes for space that contains land. If its borders can be defined and it is unoccupied, unimproved, or abandoned it can be homesteaded. (Abandoned property has some exceptions to the above rules.)
A resource like wood is in limited supply, occupies space, can be produced by labor. Additionally if I trade or sell wood that I own then I no longer own it.
Wood can be used to make fire, but fire cannot be property. Although it appears to occupy space, if I bring the fire of one torch into the space of the fire of another torch they can occupy the same space at the same time. Also if I bring my torch to an unlit torch I can share fire without diminishing the original fire, therefore it is not in limited supply and cannot be property.
A thought is not property. It doesn’t occupy space and it can be shared in unlimited quantities without diminishing the original thought, therefore a thought cannot be property.

When consistently followed, property rights produce prosperity and improve the human condition. When ignored or violated, consequences will always result.

Ben Stone Ben
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Economics, Property, Voluntaryism and Law | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0053 The Tragedy of the Commons

Note For Monday August 1, 2011

There will be no article for today.
We suffered a lightning strike on Friday evening and due to related difficulties, were unable to produce an article for Monday.
We should be back tomorrow with a new article and we are on track to have Wednesday’s podcast on time.
Please enjoy this “Best Of” article from June.
We thank you for understanding our situation and apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused.
Bad Quaker Staff

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Note For Monday August 1, 2011

0052 Impossible Rules of Engagement

0052 Impossible Rules of Engagement MP3
(audio player below article)

Impossible Rules of Engagement
by Ben Stone

When I was very young I was taught a confusing and contradictory set of rules about fighting. My father’s number one rule was for me to never throw the first punch. But my father’s other number one rule was to never let anyone push me around or “lay a rough hand” on me. And my father’s other, other number one rule was for me to never be the one who starts a fight but always be the one who finishes it. And above and beyond everything else, my father taught me to never be a bully but never submit to a bully. So in actual conflicts I could not allow myself to be bullied, pushed around, or aggressively handled, but I wasn’t allowed to strike first and it was required of me to win every physical conflict. This is an impossible standard. Tactically speaking, it simply can’t work. If I am never to throw the first punch, what am I to do while my opponent is bullying, pushing and manhandling me?

My mother would try to help me with the advice that I should use words to diffuse conflicts. The problem with that was that when I was around anyone other than family I was slow of speech and was a borderline stutter. To make matters worse, I was considerably larger than the average boy my age and we almost never lived in the same place for more than a year or two, which meant I was always the new kid. So I was a bully magnet attracting every little junior thug who had something to prove.

Even though I was almost always the youngest in my class, public school teachers would take one look at my size and my speech and, without bothering to check my records, would assume I was a problem student who had been held back a grade or two. This usually made matters worse since very often the class bully was also the teacher’s pet, as the teachers were completely out of touch with what was actually going on in their classrooms and on the playground. So no matter who started a conflict I was always singled out to carry the blame. At times I wasn’t even involved in the fight and yet somehow the teacher would snatch me out of the crowd and I would be the one in the principal’s office. I learned it was better to sit quietly and accept punishment than try to explain the situation and get punished anyway.

At home I was constantly “rough-housing” with my brother who was twelve years my senior. We watched the fake “wrestling” on TV and practiced the moves almost daily. When I was 5 years old my brother started a rigorous exercise routine to prepare himself for entry into the US Marines, so I was right there by his side doing hundreds of push-ups and thousands of sit-ups. By the age of 6, I was probably the only 2nd grader in the San Jose Public School System with washboard abs who could do one handed pull-ups and double-clap push-ups.

Humans are amazingly adaptable creatures. Given the impossible task of dealing with stupid teachers, aggressive bullies, and impossible rules of engagement, I developed a sort of informal martial art. Utilizing wrestling moves along with my superior physical condition and size, as soon as a bully started his routine I would either sweep his feet or grapple him to the ground, quickly throwing him into a chokehold. Then I would await the inevitable authority figure to break things up and punish me. This solution fulfilled all of the requirements my father had placed upon me, as I didn’t strike my opponent, and it served to humiliate the bully. Sure, I always got punished when a teacher or some other tax eater arrived, but I was being punished either way so that didn’t matter.

That policy served me well through most of my school years, but with time I could see some adjustments were needed. For example, I was with some friends at a baseball game cheering for my cousin and his team, when fans of the opposing team decided to teach us that their town was far better than our town. They began throwing rocks at us. Being the largest male in our group, it was my task to challenge the lead rock thrower. But as I marched up to him, and before I could grab him or sweep his feet, he punched me in the nose. Three times. Choking, spitting blood, and momentarily unable to see, I was filled with rage and lunged at my opponent. He wisely ran, jumped on a bicycle and took off across the parking lot. So the lesson learned was that a fist has both a speed and a reach advantage to a grappling move. And an upper body strike can happen faster than a leg sweep. So I decided to never again allow anyone the opportunity to strike me first. That was the last time a fist touched my head. I adopted the same opinion of my father’s rules as I had of the school’s rules. And once I developed my hand speed, I settled on a new tactic. As soon as my opponent was within range, I would feign a punch by slightly jerking my left hand, causing him to raise his hands defensively. Anyone not seeing my left hand move would assume he was taking a fighting stance. At that point I would deliver a quick right hook followed by a flurry of punches, finishing the fight and usually rendering my opponent either unconscious or bleeding so badly he had no heart to continue. In addition, I learned to hurt my opponent as quickly and as severely as possible so that he would never again want to face me. As a young adult, this new policy worked well when the police would show up since witnesses would generally agree that I was simply defending myself.

This is the part of the article where I’m suppose to tie this all together with something relevant that my reader can apply to their life today. Otherwise it just gets classified as the ramblings of an old fat man remembering his glory days. I hope I can pull this off, as I actually have two points I want to make.

Let’s start by looking at my father and his rules of engagement. You see, my father had several strengths and only a few weaknesses. As a child, he taught himself to read at the age of four, by looking at newspaper comics. By the age of 12 he decided school had nothing more to offer so he quit. That year his family bought their first automobile, a Ford Model-T truck. He wanted to see what made it work, so he disassembled and reassembled the engine. In one day. At the age of 14 he left home to see what adventures life had available for him. He began moving from place to place and from job to job. As an adult he was a brilliant inventor, engineer, mechanic, and tinkerer. In his minds eye he could look inside a machine and imagine all its parts as they performed their symphony, and with almost magical ability he could fix or improve almost anything that man had created. Given a task that no machine had been built to do, my dad would retreat to his shop and conjure a device perfect for the job. However, life was not easy for my father. As a boy my dad suffered a horrible accident. At the age of 9 he lost most of his left hand and fingers, leaving him a stub almost resembling a pigs foot. So credit his superior intellect, his silver tongue, or pity for his disfigurement, throughout his life he never actually fought an actual fistfight. You can see then that his rules of engagement were strictly theoretical and terribly flawed.

I would compare my father’s judgment on personal combat to those rules of engagement laid upon members of the US Military by both the clueless civilian population and the chicken hawks that hold the reins of power in Washington DC. American warriors are given an absolutely impossible task and are expected to accomplish this task by engaging in behavior detrimental to their success, all the while the State Department seems to do everything it can possibly do to get the US Military involved in as many countries as possible by constantly provoking more aggression.

Wise economists of the Austrian School of Though say all this war mongering is happening because the idiots in Washington believe the old superstition that war is good for the economy. So they use the fear and ignorance of the public to whip the nation into a froth over this threat or that, whatever or whoever the devil of the day needs to be to feed the flames of war. I have no doubt the economists are right as far as their theory goes, but I see a more sinister evil driving the State than mere stupidity.

Without getting into yet another attack on the State and its need for constant war, let me say something far simpler that I believe to be true. Free people need warriors, but war itself should be the last resort and not entered into unless you are willing to unleash your warriors to do their art, unhampered by the rules of polite society. War should never be a tool of government to accomplish some end result. War should be brief and brutal, eliminating a threat with extreme measures. The old saying “Cry Havoc! And let slip the Dogs of War!” holds within it a principle. If there is an actual threat, have at it with every once of your being and crush that threat. But when you use superior strength and technology to intimidate other nations into behaving the way you want them to behave you are simply being a bullying and you should be crushed.

My second point is a bit different. It has to do with the left-handed flinch that I mentioned and how I used it to draw a reaction from my opponent, therefore justifying the follow-through right hook. I did this move as a form of protection from authority. I could justify sending my opponent to the hospital by witnesses agreeing that I was not the aggressor. I could have followed my father’s rules and allowed him to hit me first, but after experiencing that once I decided I didn’t like the result. But the State has no such pain mechanism to teach it new behavior. So it continues sticking its nose out there asking for someone to punch it. And when it has stuck its nose in enough places, someone always punches it. Except when this happens it’s not the State that bleeds because the State has no blood of its own. When the State provokes action, people bleed. People like the ones on board the RMS Lusitania on May 7th, 1915, or the ones who happened to be in the wrong place on December 7th, 1941, or September 11, 2001. But again, the State has no pain mechanism so it has no reason to change its behavior.

So Washington DC continues to provoke war, while binding its warriors, never learning and always expanding. Answering to no one as it has its way with weaker nations.

Ben StoneBen
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker and War., The Campfire | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

0051 Meet My Benefactor

0051 Meet My Benefactor
(audio player below article)

Article taken from:
It’s a Jetsons World:
Private Miracles and Public Crimes
by Jeffrey A Tucker

Read by Ki Vick

Free Association, Peace, and Plenty

Meet My Benefactor

By pure luck, I happened to sit down next to a man last week who has been my benefactor for my entire life and the large part of his, and yet we had never met. In fact, though he has been serving me faithfully for three decades, looking after my well-being and trying to improve my standard of living, he didn’t even know my name. Actually he still doesn’t, because it is slightly odd to get too personal with the guy in the next seat on a plane. We all know this. And yet I did tell him of my deep gratitude for all he has done.Jeffrey Tucker

READ MORE HERE The PDF Version is available free at Mises.org

Posted in Audio Articles, Economics | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0051 Meet My Benefactor

0050 Episode 15 Steampunk and History Threads

Episode 15 Bad Quaker Podcast
with Ben and Ki

Featured in this episode:

  • Steampunk in TV and movies
  • The Renaissance Faire and Steampunk
  • The rise of the corporate State and the death of steam
  • The State handed the oil industry to the corporations
  • Teddy Roosevelt, a man’s man and a complete nut case
  • Carl G. Fisher, hero of business and private road builder
  • Private roads coast to coast and Dixie to Canada
  • Steampunk and worlds that could have been

Original Intro/Exit music by Grenades?!

0050 Episode 15 Steampunk and History Threads

Posted in All Podcasts, Bad Quaker and the Constitution of The United States, Bad Quaker and War., Bad Quaker Fun, Economics, Free Society, History, The Campfire, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

0049 The Olive Bar, the State, and Rule Ambiguity

0049 The Olive Bar, the State, and Rule Ambiguity MP3 It's a Jetsons World
(audio player below article)

Article taken from:
It’s a Jetsons World:
Private Miracles and Public Crimes
by Jeffrey A Tucker

Free Association, Peace, and Plenty

 

The Olive Bar, the State, and Rule Ambiguity

THERE I STOOD WITH eight olive pits in my cheek, talking
to the checkout lady at the grocery store as she waved my
half-pound container of antipasto over the scanner light. All the
while, I hoped she that she wouldn’t notice or ask why I sounded like I
had marbles in my mouth.
Like many shoppers before and after, I had been standing at the olive
bar “sampling” red, green, and black olives—first the ones without seeds,
so that there would be no evidence of my deed, then the ones stuffed
with cheese and garlic, and then finally the ones with seeds because I
couldn’t resist the temptation. Jeffrey Tucker

READ MORE HERE The PDF Version is available free at Mises.org

Posted in Audio Articles, Economics, Free Society, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

0048 Breaking the Do-Loop

0048 Breaking the Do-Loop MP3
(audio player below article)

Breaking the Do-Loop
by Ben Stone

I have a repeating thought. It’s a question that pops into my head over and over every day. Each time I encounter one of the many failings of the State I can’t help but ask myself, “Why do people continue tolerating this?”
I know this is a common problem because I see someone asking this question on the internet almost every day. And the bad part for an anarchist is that the more we understand the true nature of the State, the more shortcomings we see and the more we ask that question. It’s a self-perpetuating do-loop.

I should explain what a do-loop is.
A do-loop is used in computer programming where you want a program or hardware to continue doing something over and over until a specific condition changes. So for example, security software that monitors motion in an empty room could tell a motion detector to send out a burst of microwaves. At that point an “if-then-else” construct either repeats the loop or sounds an alarm, according to the result of the construct.

(1) send microwave burst
(2) measure speed and quantity of burst echo
(3) compare to last sample
(if-then-else) if sample same as last sample then go-to (1) else go-to (4)
(4) sound alarm

In this example the do-loop would remain 123123123123123 etc until something comes into the field of observation in which case it would become 1234.
One thing a computer programmer has to watch for is a continuous do-loop. Due to an oversight or error, a program can get stuck in a do-loop with no way to get out. Not too many years ago this was a common cause of the famous Blue Screen of Death, which is becoming an endangered species with more advanced computers and better programming.

An example of a social version of the continuous do-loop is in the Prisoner’s Dilemma (PD) of game theory developed by the RAND Corporation. The PD goes like this:
The police have two people in custody for a crime but they lack evidence for a conviction of that crime. The police separate the two and make them each the same offer; Rat out your buddy, he will get a year in jail and you walk free. But if your buddy rats you out and you don’t rat him out, he walks and you get a year in jail. If you both rat each other out you will both get 3 months. If you both stay silent you will both be given 1 month on some trumped up lesser charge. The PD is used to justify the existence of the State because the way the theory plays out, the prisoners will always cut a deal and will always serve 3 months. They would be better to stay silent, but due to distrust and selfishness they both always rat out their buddy. If you play it out over and over the prisoners will always choose to rat each other out which is always the worst choice. According to the theory, this is the great flaw in human nature that would cause humans to be in a constant condition of all against all if not for the wonders of the State. The assumption being that without the State, people would always make harmful decisions based on distrust and the desire to get something at the expense of others. The State plays the part of an attorney who communicates to both prisoners providing a safe go-between that assures both prisoners that they will get away with it if they cooperate with each other. The geniuses at the RAND Corporation believed the State interrupts this do-loop in society by providing an opportunity for people to trust each other.

The problem with the PD is that it was engineered by its designers to provide the results they were looking for to begin with. In a way, that’s why the RAND Corporation exists. To justify governments and corporations and give them the answers they want to hear. You see, the PD assumes that the nature of humans is to distrust each other and try to get something at the expense of others, and in the carefully designed Statist world of the PD they are mostly right. The State itself not only creates distrust between people it also promotes the desire to get something at the expense of others. So when the folks at RAND designed the PD, they did so not to discover the nature of humans, but to show how humans can be forced to behave in a predictable manner and be forced to depend on the State for salvation.

Consider the PD from a liberty oriented point of view. A tyrant kidnaps two people and accuses them of a crime without supporting evidence. They are forcibly separated and held incommunicado, threatened with jail, and offered a bribe for betraying their friend. The PD causes the observer to assume guilt rather than assume innocence. Also it completely leaves out human factors like friendship, devotion, and fear of long term repercussion once the guy you ratted on gets out of jail and comes looking for you. So from a liberty point of view, it’s not a prisoner’s dilemma, it’s a kidnap victim’s dilemma. And finally, for the PD to work the prisoners cannot be followers of either the Golden Rule or the Zero Aggression Principle as either would prevent the kidnap victims from helping their kidnappers for the sole purpose of saving themselves.

When open testing of the PD took place it was defeated by the tit for tat strategy also called the equivalent retaliation strategy. The basic premise here is that in a real life situation the prisoners would know that if they rat out their friend he will retaliate, and they plan on retaliation if their friend rats on them. So for this reason they treat each other in the way they wish to be treated and they refuse to rat out their friend, thus breaking the PD do-loop. And every child knows and operates by the tit for tat strategy since it is human nature and based in the same primal urges that drive the Golden rule and the Zero Aggression Principle. Actually the tit for tat strategy is represented in the Zero Aggression Principle through the law of property rights and the right to defend one’s self and one’s property, violently if need be. Therefore even within the Statist framework of the PD, liberty prevails.

The PD scenario can only exist in a State dominated situation, so it doesn’t prove the need for the State, it shows that the only answer the State can ever offer is more dependence on the State. And the defeat of the PD with the tit for tat strategy shows that even when the State stacks the deck and controls the odds, the simple honesty of human nature and the power of the principles of liberty still overcome the lies, theft, and aggression of the State.

So then, why do people continue tolerating this silly fixed game?
I think Thomas Jefferson hit the nail on the head when he wrote the following:
Prudence, indeed, will dictate that governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shown that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such government, and to provide new guards for their future security.

Jefferson was mostly right. His philosophic flaw was based on the fact that he failed to see the difference between a government and a State. We can throw off a government whenever we want, but the State will continue until humans see it for what it is. Once that happens we won’t have to throw it off. We will only have to simply stop supporting it and it will tumble to the ground like a great brazen idol with no legs.
(end do-loop go-to liberty)

Ben Stone
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker and War., Free Society, Property, Uncategorized, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0048 Breaking the Do-Loop

0046 Washington DC’s War against Mexico

0046 Washington DC’s War against Mexico  MP3
(audio player below article)Ben

Washington DC’s War on Mexico
by Ben Stone

 

Frederic Bastiat ~ That Which is Seen and That Which is Not Seen

In the economy, an act, a habit, an institution, a law, gives birth not only to an effect, but to a series of effects. Of these effects, the first only is immediate; it manifests itself simultaneously with its cause—it is seen. The others unfold in succession—they are not seen…. Between a good and a bad economist this constitutes the whole difference—the one takes account of the visible effect; the other takes account both of the effects which are seen and also of those which it is necessary to foresee. Now this difference is enormous, for it almost always happens that when the immediate consequence is favorable, the ultimate consequences are fatal…..

 

I was reading a story on a liberal web site about how corn subsidies lower the market prices on a variety of junk foods therefore making them more cost effective for poor people to purchase. The result being that the poorest people in the US eat the most unhealthy foods while the more affluent can afford healthy alternatives. Of course the author, being a liberal statist, was only noticing one tiny suction cup of the massive tentacle of US farm subsidies that distort the market and ruin people’s lives around the world. But sadly, as I read the article, I couldn’t help noticing the implied solution was to simply subsidize “good food” while bringing down the hammer of regulation on the “bad food”.

This tendency of willful ignorance and blind support of the expansion of the State is not unique to liberals. For every 1 liberal I have struggled with, trying to show them that their State/god is incapable of fixing the problems it creates, I have wrestled with 10 conservatives trying to show them that brute force and more laws only grow the State and drive taxes and spending ever higher. If I could say it clearer than Bastiat I would, but whether in his words or mine the majority of the time the sound of my voice is lost in the roar of the State’s propaganda, driving the liberal towards more nanny regulations and driving the conservative to “get tough”.

A typical hot button with a conservative is the illegal immigration issue. At the mere mention of the topic the whole of the Right Wing explodes into rhythmic chants demanding tougher laws and brutal crackdowns. Speak of crime, gangs, or the drug problem and the State’s faithful congregation will jump to its feet in open praise of a stronger fist and a heavier boot. Sadly, the logic of cause and effect are swept to the side as the emotions of nationalism take the pulpit. The fact that the State created the problem completely escapes the glare of the limelight as reason slips off the stage and out the side door.

Corn is just the beginning.
I wonder if the average reader of this article knows that because of US corn subsidies, the price has fallen by 2/3 in the last 20 years. Generally I’m all for lower prices, but when a government involves itself in a market so dramatically as to create such a false price, you can bet there will be huge repercussions in unimaginable places. But corn is just the beginning. The price of sugar is just as false, but manipulated in the opposite direction. And neither corn nor sugar can hold a light for the price manipulation that the rice market suffers.

The reader may be wondering at this point, why I am bouncing from crime, gangs, drugs, and immigration to Right/Left politics and farm subsidies. Well, I’m not bouncing. They are the same thing. Remember those faithful words of Bastiat about the seen and the unseen. The very reason governments should stay out of markets is because they are incapable of connecting the dots and seeing the association between their actions and the consequences of those actions. But I am here for you, my reader, with a big black marker to show you how these dots connect.

You see, the poor farmers of Mexico used to feed their families by growing three money making crops; corn, rice, and sugar cane. Then the intellectuals in their ivy-covered universities decided that the living standard in rural Mexico was too low and the farmers needed to stop farming and move into Mexican cities where they can work in low-end manufacturing. So at the same time the US ratcheted up its price manipulations with farm subsidies, NAFTA opened Mexico to a flood of corn that the farmers couldn’t compete against, and yet restrictions keep Mexican rice and sugar from flowing north.

Imagine yourself a Mexican farmer, just getting by on a living you scratch from the ground, in fields your family has tilled longer than there is memory to tell. Then the weak corrupt government in Mexico City makes a deal with the strong corrupt government in Washington DC, and your only source of livelihood is gone. The way your family has lived for centuries is taken away by people who’s faces you have never seen and names you have never heard.

That farmer has some choices.

  1. Starve and watch his children starve on the farm.
  2. Move to a dangerous slum in a Mexican city where the language is so different he almost can’t communicate, and hope he finds work.
  3. Take a chance and sneak into the US where work is available and the cities are magic wonderlands compared to the Mexican slums.
  4. Grow something profitable.

Grow something profitable.
To fully understand point 4, let me restate my accusation that the government in Mexico City is corrupt and weak. So corrupt and weak that it can’t even provide security for those living in its cities, much less control the countryside. This is actually one of the great strengths of the Mexican culture. Once you get away from the government’s influence and are submerged in the colorful freedom that rural Mexico affords its much easier to fall in love with the Mexican people and understand the depths of the tragedy that has befallen them. So in the past, a weak government was a good thing for rural Mexico. But since the US “war on drugs” has driven so much wealth into the hands of crime lords, the weak government that used to technically exist in rural Mexico is gone, leaving only the armies and private security of the drug lords. And they don’t care about the price of corn. So the farmer that chooses to stay on his farm is told in terms he cannot misunderstand that his only path to security and prosperity is to grow the crop the drug lords tell him to grow. Then when the harvest is in, the sergeants of the drug lords pick villagers who take the risk and act as human mules, carrying the drugs across the border while knowing that if they refuse or fail, their families will bear the punishment.

Jumping back to point 3 above, you can see that the US farm subsidies created a large segment of the illegal immigration problem. And with a glance at point 2 above, you may notice that the increase in the labor pool in Mexican cities drove the local wages down and attracted US manufactures to move more jobs out of US cities and into Mexico, thus devastating whole neighborhoods in Detroit, Chicago, Pittsburgh, Cleveland, and the list goes on.

Now that I have removed the bandages that have hidden the wound that Washington DC inflicted upon the gentle villagers and farmers of Mexico, bear with me as I reveal yet more injustices. You see, some of those farmers who left their family land had to sell that land right at a time when there was a glut of Mexican farms available on the market. However a buyer appeared. Not a person, but an invention of the State. Multi-national agribusiness swept in and gobbled up the choice farms at pennies on the dollar, driving even more small Mexican farmers out of business. And if all of the above weren’t enough, in the same time frame, 80 to 90% of the water of the Colorado river that used to go into Mexico has been diverted and the river no longer even comes close to reaching the sea, leaving whole towns in the delta abandoned.

Of course, growing cities in the US needed that water for important things like the fountains, magic volcanoes and gondola rides in Las Vegas and the expanses of golf courses in Scottsdale and Palm Springs. But don’t think that water was all wasted on fun things the poor Mexicans can’t even imagine existing. Have a drive into California’s Imperial Valley where old leaky broken canals carry the water from the Colorado River into alfalfa fields, and you’ll see why it was necessary to dry up the river delta and force the Cocopah Indians off of their ancestral lands. Its true that some of that water makes its way to Los Angeles and supports the residents. But those residents pay a 4600% higher price than the agribusiness alfalfa growers. And what happens to all that alfalfa? The vast majority goes to the heavily subsidized US dairy industry where a USDA cartel markets its products with fixed prices and government guaranteed purchases, eliminating its competition at the point of the State’s gun.

Lets recap this article, just for kicks and giggles.

~Traditional Mexican farmers supported themselves by growing corn, rice and sugar cane.

~The State has systematically manipulated the price and controlled the distribution of corn, rice, and sugar, practically eliminating the ability of Mexican farmers to continue their traditional lifestyle and making many of them slaves to the drug lords.

~The State’s war on drugs has enriched drug lords, enabling them to become a virtual State in northern Mexico.

~NAFTA’s attempt to enrich the lives of Mexican farmers, whether they wanted it or not, by driving them into the cities, resulted in both job losses in US cities and an increase in illegal immigration into the US.

~With an increased flow of illegal immigration into ever poorer US cities and richer more powerful drug lords funneling drugs through the gangs into those cities, crime results.

~Multi-national agribusiness not only absorbs massive amounts of tax dollars through direct subsidies and State price controls, it also expands itself by scooping up cheap land as family farmers are squished.

~Agribusiness along with international gaming corporations and city governments (and their crony golf buddies) steal water from some of the poorest people in the western hemisphere so they can offer such niceties as artificially priced State regulated gelato vodka smoothies to tourists who stare drunkenly at a fake pyramid.

Oh, and we are suppose to believe that this is capitalism.

Having considered all of the above, I have to wonder how long it will be before the wise overlords in Washington DC decide the Mexican government has failed and the US military yet again sweeps into Sonora, and Chihuahua, and Marines once more march into the halls of Montezuma.

Ben Stone
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker and Taxes, Bad Quaker and War., Economics, History, Liberals and Conservatives, Property | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

0041 Episode 14 Meet Ki and Listener Question

Episode 14 Bad Quaker Podcast

Choose

with Ben and Ki

Featured in this episode:

  • Get to know Ki
  • Working the Renaissance Faire circuit
  • Free market living with Rennies
  • Raising children in a free market
  • The Horse Story and living outdoors
  • Unexpected black markets, barter, radio stations and restaurants
  • Listener question: Is it moral to do business with the State?
  • Should we be angry at the rich who dodge taxes?

0041 Episode 14 Meet Ki and Listener Question

Posted in All Podcasts, Bad Quaker and Taxes, Bad Quaker and the Constitution of The United States, Bad Quaker Fun, Economics, Free Society, Property, The Campfire, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0041 Episode 14 Meet Ki and Listener Question

0044 Socially Liberal, Fiscally Conservative

Audio Version of
Socially Liberal, Fiscally Conservative
By Ben Stone Ben

Featured in this episode:

  • The failure of the American Left/Right political machine has caused an increase in the number of libertarians
  • New libertarians grapple with a way to explain themselves to friends and family
  • Libertarians are not socially liberal and fiscally conservative
  • Libertarianism is a consistent philosophy based on the Zero Aggression Principle

0044 Socially Liberal, Fiscally Conservative

Posted in Audio Articles, History, Liberals and Conservatives, Property, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment